Choosing The Best Leadership Coach


Did you know that about 25% of all coaching relationships have to be terminated? That’s the finding from an AMA research study. When most experienced coaches are polled, another study found that almost half felt that unqualified coaches threaten the effectiveness of coaching.

As a professional executive leadership coach, I am constantly interviewed for assignments as well as interviewing other prospective coaches for my clients. Rarely, are we put through a rigorous screening process, so it’s no wonder some poor hires make it through to the intended coachees. How do you know what to look for in a quality executive leadership coach? And what is the best fit for your organization?

Download my presentation on Choosing the Best Leadership Coach and Maximizing Results to learn how to select the best leadership coach for you and your organization. You’ll also learn how to leverage that relationship to enhance leadership development and achieve stronger results.


Guidelines for choosing an executive coach

3 Top Coaching Tips for Derailers: Mischievous


As part of our blog series “3 Top Coaching Tips for Derailers“, we will take a look at each of the 11 behavioral traits identified by Hogan’s research that cause leaders to derail and include examples with suggestions to overcome each derailing behavioral trait. This week, we highlight the derailing behavior Mischievous.

Some level of Mischievous behavior can become good for your career. It’s when you take it to the extreme that you can cross the line and violate policies and even laws. The landscape is filled with fallen CEO’s who pushed the limits of Mischievous behaviors including the most extreme examples with Ken Lay and Bernie Madoff. Leaders who possess this trait to a moderate degree may push the limits that result in creativity and innovation in their organizations. They use their charm for good reasons to achieve organizational goals.


The leader should continue: Treating clients and colleagues with respect and support

The leader should stop: Ignoring warnings, cautions, and feedback about your unnecessary risk taking

The leader should begin:

  • Partnering with someone who is good with details and follow-up
  • Weighing true consequences of different courses of action
  • Remembering that others may not be as adventurous as you
  • Taking ownership for what you are doing
  • Determining which rules really are important to follow and follow them consistently

Leaders can be assessed using the Hogan suite of assessments which are very helpful to leaders by increasing their self-awareness and gaining a better understanding of why they are not getting the results required in their roles.


3 Top Coaching Tips for Derailers: Excitable

cps coaching tips for derailers 002

Many leaders start to exhibit derailing behaviors when faced with stress. These particular behaviors may have helped them succeed in the past and have been reinforced over time as acceptable for their careers. Stress may be caused by excessive workloads, goals difficulty, tight timelines, poor team performance and more obstacles that could cause a leader to believe he or she may fail. Hogan has identified 11 traits that all leaders possess. Their research has shown when these are over-used during stressful conditions derailing behaviors occur.

As part of our new blog series “3 Top Coaching Tips for Derailers”, we will take a look at each of the 11 behavioral traits identified by Hogan and include examples with suggestions to overcome each derailing behavior.


I was coaching a senior leader who was a President at the time running a very large manufacturing facility producing consumer products. In his case, when I interviewed his team to collect confidential information about his leadership style he was described as “running hot and cold” on ideas and people. He would start something and put a lot of energy and time into getting it going and then seemingly lose interest and start something else. An often cited example was that he felt the parking lot car spacing lines had to be painted a certain way in dimensions and his team disagreed and also wondered why he was so involved in something like that vs. bigger picture issues and opportunities.

coaching tips for derailers

When coaching the President, who expressed frustration over not being able to get his team behind initiatives, he told me that when faced with resistance (often) he would just back off and quit pushing something. So, he was caught in this leadership dilemma of seemingly not able to get his team to follow his direction on all his new ideas. The team perceived him as having all these ideas that were good for a few weeks, so if they waited and did nothing, it would blow over and another idea would come their way from the President. This pattern had been repeated many times over the years. Once this was discovered by the President he realized what he had been doing and we changed his approach to motivating his team on key initiatives. When the President’s assessment results became available he had scored in the High Risk area for Excitable.

He was a perfect example of the excitable derailer; someone who ranges from emotional calmness to being moody, hard to please, and with a tendency to show emotional ups and downs.


The leader should continue:  Acting with passion, energy and enthusiasm

The leader should stop:  Losing emotional control and yelling at everyone

The leader should begin:

  • Analyzing upsetting situations to understand triggers
  • Recognizing signs of an impending loss of control
  • Leaving the situation, taking a “time out”
  • Moderating your initial enthusiasm about people and projects to avoid being discouraged later
  • Avoiding defeatist thinking when you encounter problems
  • Making sure good implementers are on the team for when your excitement wears off

Leaders can be assessed using the Hogan suite of assessments which are very helpful to leaders by increasing their self-awareness and gaining a better understanding of why they are not getting the results required in their roles.

Look for our blog series to continue in the next few weeks with coaching tips for the other derailing behaviors identified by Hogan.